San Mateo's Best Steak House [Updated 2025]

Having explored a variety of dining options, I’ve reviewed a dozen steakhouses in the area, each offering a unique twist on this beloved classic.

From sizzling cuts to mouthwatering sides, the quest for the perfect steak is both an adventure and a passion of mine.

Join me as I share the standout features of these establishments, highlighting my favorites based on quality, flavor, and atmosphere.

Whether you're a seasoned steak lover or simply curious about local culinary gems, this guide will help you find the ideal spot to satisfy your cravings in San Mateo.

Porterhouse

Highlights
Quality steak options
Excellent Tomahawk steak
Reasonable wine markups
Enjoyable atmosphere
Unique banana flambé dessert

Porterhouse in San Mateo beckoned me with the promise of a steak lover’s paradise, and it did not disappoint! The moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped by an enjoyable atmosphere that made me feel right at home. The lighting was just dim enough to foster intimate conversations while still allowed me to admire the beautifully grilled cuts of meat on other tables.

As I perused the menu, my eyes honed in on their excellent Tomahawk steak. And oh, what a choice! Cooked to perfection, the steak was juicy, tender, and seasoned wonderfully, making each bite an explosion of flavor. The reasonable wine markups made it easy to pair my meal with a glass that elevated the entire dining experience.

But let me not forget the grand finale—the unique banana flambé dessert! It was the perfect way to round off a remarkable meal, igniting a delightful sweetness that was both nostalgic and sophisticated.

If you’re searching for a steak house that offers quality, ambiance, and a dash of culinary flair, Porterhouse is your destination. I left with my taste buds dancing and my heart full, eagerly anticipating my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best clam chowder in San Francisco.

San Mateo Prime

Highlights
Excellent Prime Rib
Attentive and Friendly Service
Great Wine Selection
Delicious Meat Dishes
Affordable Fine Dining

San Mateo Prime has grilled its way into my heart with their sensational take on classic steakhouse fare. As I stepped into the warmly lit dining room, I was greeted by an ambiance that just screams “fine dining,” yet feels inviting. The attentive and friendly service made me feel like royalty without the stuffiness that often comes with such establishments.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the excellent prime rib. Cooked to perfection, every bite was a juicy revelation that made me question my previous devotion to other cuts. The flavor was rich and savory, elevating the experience to new heights. Paired with their great wine selection, my meal transformed into a culinary journey that I wished would never end.

What pleasantly surprised me was that this remarkable experience didn’t come with a jaw-dropping price tag—affordable fine dining is a rarity worth celebrating. The delicious meat dishes don’t just stop at the prime rib; the whole menu is a carnivore’s paradise.

In a nutshell, if you’re hunting for the best steak in San Mateo, let me save you some time: San Mateo Prime is, without a doubt, the pinnacle of tender delight.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Half Moon Bay.

Sixteen Mile House

Highlights
Delicious and hearty food
Kid-friendly atmosphere
Great for special occasions
Diverse menu options
Impressive ribeye selection

Sixteen Mile House is a delightful gem that offers both a rich culinary adventure and a warm atmosphere that feels just right for any occasion. Upon entering this establishment, I was immediately struck by its inviting vibe, perfect for families and special celebrations alike. The kid-friendly atmosphere makes it a fantastic choice for those dining out with the little ones, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied.

Now, let’s get to the star of the show—the food. I savored a mouthwatering ribeye that was not just cooked to perfection, but left me dreaming about my next visit. Their diverse menu options cater to every palate, but let’s be honest, steak lovers will find it hard to resist the enticing selections here. I must say, the hearty portions were so generous that I found myself contemplating the possibility of a doggy bag—even though I was reluctant to part with any of that deliciousness!

In a nutshell, Sixteen Mile House encapsulates everything one might want in a steakhouse experience. It’s a wonderful blend of fine dining and casual comfort, making it rise above its competitors in San Mateo. If you’re on the hunt for the best steak in town, look no further than this charming spot!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in San Francisco.

Town

Highlights
Great food & wine selections
Friendly & efficient service
Nice ambiance
Interesting menu options
Outstanding French toast

Visiting Town in San Mateo was an absolute pleasure that tantalized my taste buds and warmed my heart. As I stepped inside, I was immediately enveloped by a charming ambiance that set the perfect backdrop for a delightful evening. The friendly and efficient service made me feel like a VIP, which is always a cherry on top when dining out.

Now, let's talk about the bewitching menu! I was thrilled to find an array of interesting options that spoke to my adventurous side. I decided on their signature steak, and let me tell you, it was a carnivorous delight! Perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection, it melted in my mouth and had me craving just one more bite.

To complement my meal, I indulged in an exquisite wine selection that danced beautifully with the flavors on my plate. And as a delightful surprise, I couldn’t resist the outstanding French toast for dessert, which added a perfect sweet finish to my culinary adventure.

Overall, Town is a must-visit for steak lovers in San Mateo. With its fantastic food, warm service, and inviting atmosphere, it’s clear why it's a standout in the heart of the city.

You might also want to check out the best dim sum in Chinatown.

Broadway Prime

Highlights
Best prime rib experience
Kind and generous owner
Beautiful and perfectly lit ambiance
Mixed service experiences
Inconsistent food quality

Nestled in the heart of San Mateo, Broadway Prime is a delightful find for steak lovers like me. From the moment I stepped inside, the beautifully lit ambiance wrapped around me like a warm hug, setting the perfect tone for an evening of indulgence. The owner greeted me with a kindness that felt genuine, making me feel instantly welcome.

Now let’s talk about the star of the show: the prime rib. Oh, what a masterpiece! The flavors danced on my palate, each bite a testament to culinary excellence. However, I must mention that my companions experienced some inconsistencies in their dishes, which created a mixed bag of satisfaction across our table.

While the service was charmingly attentive at times, it occasionally felt like it was playing hide and seek—there were moments of delightful attention and some where we were left twiddling our thumbs. Nonetheless, Broadway Prime is a charming spot worth visiting. With its rich flavors and inviting atmosphere, it’s a steakhouse that leaves you craving just one more bite. For a memorable experience, this is a place you won't want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Francisco.

Broadway Grill

Highlights
Delicious food
Friendly staff
Live music events
Great for special occasions
Refreshing cocktails

Broadway Grill is truly a hidden gem in San Mateo that makes for an unforgettable dining experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff, who not only exuded warmth but also made me feel like a valued guest. This sense of hospitality is part of what sets Broadway Grill apart.

Now, let’s talk steak! The food was absolutely delicious—I opted for their signature ribeye, which was perfectly cooked and seasoned. Each bite was tender and packed with flavor, making it clear that this establishment takes steak seriously.

But the experience goes beyond just the food; the unique atmosphere is amplified by live music events that weave through the ambiance, creating a wonderful backdrop for a delightful meal. It’s an excellent spot for special occasions or just a casual night out.

And don’t forget to indulge in their refreshing cocktails. They offer a fantastic selection that pairs beautifully with the steak.

In short, if you're hunting for the best steak house in San Mateo, Broadway Grill should be at the top of your list. You won't leave disappointed—trust me!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Francisco Little Italy.

Rise Woodfire San Mateo

Highlights
Unique indoor/outdoor vibe
Warm and welcoming atmosphere
Friendly and fast service
Fresh and crispy salads
Creative pizza options

Rise Woodfire San Mateo is a delightful gem that captures the essence of casual dining with an elegant twist! As I walked into this steak haven, the unique indoor/outdoor vibe immediately set the mood. The blend of rustic decor and open air made me feel as if I had found my perfect culinary escape.

The warm and welcoming atmosphere embraced me like an old friend. Staff members greeted me with genuine smiles, and their friendly and fast service was commendable. I was impressed by how they struck the right balance: attentive yet unobtrusive—something often hard to achieve!

While the stars of the menu are undoubtedly the steaks, I couldn’t resist exploring some of their fresh and crispy salads to start. Each bite was a burst of flavor, showcasing their commitment to fresh ingredients. And let’s not overlook their creative pizza options! A perfect choice for a fun shareable dish!

Overall, Rise Woodfire nailed it on multiple fronts. With their delicious offerings, stellar service, and captivating ambiance, it's clear why many consider it a top contender in San Mateo’s steakhouse scene. I’ll definitely be back for more of that wood-fired magic!

You might also want to check out the best food in Alameda.

Taurus Steakhouse San Carlos

Highlights
Fresh oysters from Japan
Industrial club-like vibe
Friendly service
Tough ribeye steak
Delicious fried ube

When I stepped into Taurus Steakhouse San Carlos, I was immediately struck by its industrial club-like vibe—a perfect blending of sophistication and comfort that invites you to kick back and enjoy a leisurely evening. To start, I ordered the fresh oysters from Japan, which were a delightful precursor to the main event. Each slurp offered a briny burst that tantalized my taste buds.

As for the steak, I opted for the ribeye, a choice I usually revel in. However, I found it to be somewhat tough, leaving me wishing for a more tender cut. Fortunately, the friendly service more than made up for it, with the staff keen to ensure my dining experience was just right.

Now, let’s talk about sides! I couldn't resist trying the delicious fried ube, a unique twist that added a delightful sweetness to my plate. Overall, my visit was a rollercoaster of flavors, making Taurus Steakhouse a memorable spot in San Mateo. While the ribeye may have fallen short, the atmosphere, service, and inventive sides certainly shone. If you’re in the area, don’t miss this hidden gem—it’s worth a visit for the experience alone!

You might also want to check out the best cookies in San Francisco.

The Refuge (San Mateo)

Highlights
Tender, well-seasoned pastrami
Indulgent Goofy Fries
Casual, relaxed ambiance
Hearty, flavorful dishes
Perfect for informal gatherings

Nestled in the heart of San Mateo, The Refuge is a delightful gem that delights meat lovers like me! From the moment I stepped inside, the casual, relaxed ambiance instantly set the tone for a memorable evening. I decided to kick off my meal with their renowned tender, well-seasoned pastrami—a dish that could easily steal the spotlight at any steak house.

But let’s not forget about the indulgent Goofy Fries! These tantalizingly crispy morsels are topped with cheese and an array of flavors that make them utterly irresistible. They’re perfect for sharing—or not. Who am I kidding? I could’ve kept them all to myself!

What impressed me the most were the hearty, flavorful dishes that cater to a variety of palates. Each bite exudes a passion for delicious cuisine that I truly appreciate. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a place to unwind with friends, The Refuge offers the perfect backdrop for informal gatherings. If you’re in search of an exceptional steak house experience in San Mateo, don’t miss out on this delightful spot! You might just find yourself saying, “I’ll be back!”

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in San Francisco.

Sundance The Steakhouse

Highlights
Prime Rib Expertise
Delicious Mushroom Side
Busy and Vibrant Atmosphere
Accommodating and Honest Staff
Must Make Reservations

Sundance The Steakhouse is truly a hidden gem that bursts with flavor and vibrancy! As I stepped in, the lively atmosphere immediately caught my attention, abuzz with conversation and laughter—perfect for a wonderful night out! I wasted no time in ordering their renowned prime rib, and it did not disappoint! Cooked to perfection, the tender meat practically melted in my mouth, enveloped in rich flavors that left me wishing for another slice.

But wait, there's more! The sides at Sundance are not to be overlooked, especially the savory mushroom side that added an earthy richness to my meal, complementing the prime rib beautifully. I must say, the staff was exceptionally accommodating and honest, guiding me through their extensive menu with ease. Their recommendations were spot on!

However, a word of advice: make sure to reserve a table ahead of time! The restaurant tends to fill up quickly, and I can see why. If you’re in San Mateo and craving a steak that dances on your palate, Sundance The Steakhouse is definitely the place to indulge. I left with a full belly and a happy heart, eagerly planning my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best eats in San Francisco.

Mykonos

Highlights
Nice family dinner ambiance
Good typical Greek dishes
Friendly and accommodating staff
Great food presentation
Positive dining experience

Mykonos Review

Walking into Mykonos, I was instantly embraced by a cozy atmosphere that felt perfect for a family dinner. The ambiance, warm and inviting, set the tone for what would be an unforgettable evening. Now, while this delightful Mediterranean eatery isn't strictly a steakhouse, it certainly offers a noteworthy selection of grilled meats that deserve a spot on your culinary radar.

I couldn't help but indulge in their grilled steak, which was perfectly prepared and boasted a wonderful char. Each bite was a testament to their attention to detail and quality. The food presentation was eye-catching, bringing a feast for both the eyes and taste buds!

What truly made my experience shine was the friendly and accommodating staff, who went above and beyond to ensure my dining experience was nothing short of spectacular. They were knowledgeable about the menu, recommending their excellent Greek dishes that complemented the meat perfectly.

In conclusion, Mykonos might just surprise you with its steak offerings amidst the Mediterranean charm. It's more than just a meal; it's a positive dining experience that would leave you smiling long after the last bite. If you're in San Mateo, don't overlook this gem!

Pacific Catch

Highlights
Great food for health
Wide variety of menu options
Good size outdoor dining area
Quick lunch/dinner spot
Group-friendly atmosphere

Pacific Catch in San Mateo isn’t your traditional steak house, but don't let that mislead you; this place is a hidden gem offering delectable dishes that transcend the ordinary. My visit was a delightful surprise as I walked into a vibrant atmosphere filled with laughter and the clinking of glasses. The outdoor dining area is a fantastic option, especially when the sun is shining, providing a refreshing backdrop to enjoy your meal.

The menu is impressively diverse, showcasing a wide array of options that appeal to health-conscious diners without sacrificing flavor. I indulged in a perfectly cooked grilled steak that was both tender and bursting with flavor. The quick service here makes it an ideal spot for lunch or a casual dinner, fitting seamlessly into a busy schedule.

It’s rare to find a place that caters so well to both individuals and groups, making it easy for friends to gather around a table and share lively conversations over plates of vibrant dishes. If you’re in the mood for a steak that delights your taste buds and offers a refreshing twist, I highly recommend checking out Pacific Catch. This isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience worth savoring!