San Carlos' Best Pizza

Pizza in San Carlos is a game of expectations, and most places lose. Blue Line’s cornmeal crust is the clear winner, but the rest of the list is a scatterplot.

You can get a crab sandwich at a World Cup bar, or fried olives at a Greek spot on Laurel Street. One place runs a prix fixe menu with locally sourced greens, another serves schnitzel with mushroom gravy.

A wine bar treats pizza as a pairing exercise. Tandoori chicken is worth a drive to Foster City.

None of it is generic. Read on and sort it out.

Blue Line Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza on peninsula
Addictive cornmeal dough texture
Standout West Coast deep dish
Attentive, friendly table service
Distinct from Chicago-style crust

Blue Line Pizza claims the top spot on this list, and the evidence supports it. The cornmeal crust is the defining feature. It has a gritty, addictive texture that sets it apart from any dough I have tried locally. The West Coast deep dish is a standout, distinct from Chicago's heavier version. It is lighter, almost airy, yet sturdy enough to hold the toppings. Table service is attentive and friendly. I left without a single complaint. This is the best pizza on the peninsula. I have not found better.

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Hayward.

New York pizza, pasta & more

Highlights
Counter service, takeout style
Crispy thin crust available
Friendly owner, quick service
World Cup viewing, free water
Crab sandwich praised highly

New York pizza, pasta & more does not pretend to be anything else. It is counter service, takeout style. The crispy thin crust is a solid option. The owner is friendly, and service moves quickly. I watched a World Cup match there, and the free water was appreciated. The crab sandwich, however, is the real draw. It is praised highly, and rightly so. The pizza is fine. The sandwich is the reason to return. If you want a no-frills slice, this works. Just do not skip the seafood.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in San Jose.

Elia San Carlos

Highlights
Authentic Greek-style outdoor seating
Crisp, savory fried olives
Beautiful, traditional Greek presentation
Dog-friendly Laurel Street spot

Elia San Carlos is not primarily a pizza place. It is a Greek restaurant with outdoor seating. The fried olives are crisp and savory. The presentation is beautiful and traditional. The pizza, if you order it, is serviceable but not the focus. The setting is the star. Laurel Street is dog-friendly, and the atmosphere feels authentic. I appreciated the lack of pretense. It is a pleasant stop, but I would come for the olives, not the pie. The pizza is fine. It is not memorable.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Napa.

3P Wine Co.

Highlights
Expert wine and food pairings
Educational, personal tasting experience
Live chef-prepared market pairings

3P Wine Co. is a wine bar, not a pizzeria. Do not expect a standard pie here. What they offer is expert wine and food pairings. The tasting experience is educational and personal. A chef prepares market pairings live. The pizza, when offered, is a vehicle for the wine. I enjoyed the interplay of flavors. It is a different kind of pizza experience. You go for the pairings. The food supports the wine. It works, but it is not a traditional pizza joint. It is a curated evening.

You might also want to check out the best coffee places in San Francisco.

number5kitchen

Highlights
Fresh, locally sourced ingredients
Seasonal prix fixe menu
Perfectly crispy pizza crust
Cozy, family-run atmosphere

number5kitchen operates like a well-kept secret. The ingredients are fresh and locally sourced. The menu is seasonal and prix fixe. The pizza crust is perfectly crispy. I ordered it, and it delivered. The atmosphere is cozy and family-run. There is a warmth that makes you linger. The pizza is not the only reason to visit, but it is a strong one. The focus on quality is evident in every bite. I left satisfied. I will return for the crust alone.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Mountain View.

Bistro Mitte

Highlights
Schnitzel with perfect mushroom gravy
Impeccable service, clean dining room
Kasespätzle worth sharing
Reasonably priced German comfort food
Patio and indoor seating options

Bistro Mitte does not center on pizza. It is a German restaurant. The schnitzel with mushroom gravy is perfect. The service is impeccable, and the dining room is clean. The kasespätzle is worth sharing. The pizza, if available, is an afterthought. I did not order it. I ordered the schnitzel. It was reasonably priced. The patio offers a pleasant option. This is comfort food done right. If you want pizza, go elsewhere. If you want a good meal, stay here.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Stockton.

PJ's Pizza Co.

Highlights
Fresh, quality ingredients throughout
Friendly, accommodating staff always
Reliable for last-minute party orders
No heartburn after eating
Pet-friendly dining option available

PJ's Pizza Co. is a reliable neighborhood option. The ingredients are fresh and quality is consistent. The staff is friendly and accommodating. I have used them for last-minute party orders. They never miss. The pizza does not cause heartburn, which is a quiet compliment. They also allow pets on the patio. The crust is standard, the toppings are generous. It is not the best on the peninsula, but it is dependable. For a casual weeknight, it works. I have no complaints.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Milpitas.

Esnaf

Highlights
Service exceeds all expectations
Staff treat you like family
Outdoor seating evokes Europe
Menu recommendations are consistently excellent
Genuine pride in hospitality

Esnaf is not about the pizza. It is about the service. The staff exceeds all expectations. They treat you like family. The outdoor seating evokes Europe, with a relaxed pace. Recommendations from the menu are consistently excellent. I trusted them, and I was not disappointed. The pizza is decent. The hospitality is exceptional. There is genuine pride in what they do. I felt taken care of. It is a rare quality. I would return for the experience, not just the food.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Cupertino.

Tandoori Pizza - Foster City

Highlights
Unique spiced chicken toppings
Generous portions, fair price
Juicy marinated wings
Fresh, fast, friendly service
Worth returning for

Tandoori Pizza in Foster City is a worthwhile trip. The spiced chicken toppings are unique. They bring a flavor profile you will not find elsewhere. The portions are generous for the price. The wings are juicy and marinated well. Service is fresh, fast, and friendly. I ordered a pie and wings. Both were good. The crust holds up to the bold toppings. It is not traditional, but it is memorable. I would return. This is a pizza worth crossing city lines for.

You might also want to check out the best chinese restaurant in San Jose.

Rise - Woodfire Pizza & Rotisserie

Highlights
Warm converted train interior
Accommodating gluten-free requests
Fresh, crisp Italian chopped salad
Brunch pizza fits two
Date pizza inspires repeat visits

Rise Woodfire Pizza is inside a converted train car. The interior is warm and unusual. Gluten-free requests are handled without fuss. The Italian chopped salad is crisp and fresh. The brunch pizza is large enough for two. I have ordered the date pizza on repeat visits. It is consistently good. The wood fire gives a nice char. Service is efficient. The setting is a conversation starter. The pizza is better than the gimmick. I recommend it for a date or a casual meal.

You might also want to check out the best clam chowder in San Francisco.

Pazzo

Highlights
Reliable across multiple dishes
Friendly, professional service
Comfortable, home-like setting
Convenient street parking
Strong local reputation

Pazzo is a solid, unpretentious choice. It is reliable across multiple dishes. I have tried the pizza and the pasta. Both were competent. The service is friendly and professional. The setting feels like home, comfortable and unremarkable. Street parking is convenient, which is rare. The local reputation is strong for good reason. It will not wow you, but it will not disappoint. I left with no complaints. That is the highest praise I can give. It is a dependable neighborhood standby.

You might also want to check out the best donuts in San Francisco.

Impasto by Terun

Highlights
Wood-fired pizza praised
Excellent seafood risotto
Attentive, knowledgeable staff
Chic, modern ambiance
Convenient adjacent parking

Impasto by Terun is a modern spot with wood-fired pizza. The crust is excellent, blistered and chewy. I also tried the seafood risotto. It was excellent. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable. The ambiance is chic and clean. Adjacent parking makes it easy to visit. The pizza is the highlight, but the risotto is close. I would order both again. It is a step above the average pizza place. The price reflects it, but the quality is there. I left impressed.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Half Moon Bay.