San Mateo's Best Burger [Updated 2025]

Having reviewed a dozen local spots, I can confidently say that San Mateo has a vibrant burger scene that caters to all tastes.

From classic cheeseburgers to unique gourmet creations, there's something for everyone in this city.

In this article, I’ll take you on a delicious journey through my top picks, sharing what makes each burger truly special.

Get ready to indulge your taste buds and discover which burger reigns supreme in San Mateo!

The Refuge (San Mateo)

Highlights
Tender Hand-Carved Pastrami
Indulgent Goofy Fries
Casual, Relaxed Atmosphere
Hearty, Flavorful Dishes
Complementary Crunch Nachos

The Refuge (San Mateo) is a must-visit for burger enthusiasts seeking a unique twist. Walking into this vibrant eatery, the casual, relaxed atmosphere immediately invites you to unwind and indulge in hearty fare. My tastebuds were tantalized when I ordered their signature burger, paired with their famous indulgent Goofy Fries—a guilty pleasure that didn't disappoint.

Let me tell you, the burger was a masterpiece! The beef was grilled to perfection, boasting a juicy tenderness that just melted in my mouth. With every bite, I appreciated the balance of flavors, and the toppings complemented the patty beautifully. Now, that hand-carved pastrami? It’s a game changer! I couldn't resist sneaking a few bites from my companion's plate; the smoky, meaty goodness had my heart racing.

Oh, and the complimentary crunch nachos? A delightful surprise that added a wonderful texture, making it an excellent starter. All in all, my experience at The Refuge left me completely satisfied—this place is definitely among the top contenders for the best burger in San Mateo. If you're craving something delicious, make sure to stop by; you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best clam chowder in San Francisco.

Swing Shift San Mateo

Highlights
Unique global cuisine variety
Flavorful burger options
Delicious crunchy chicharrones
Sophisticated mocktails
Savory tri tip chili

At Swing Shift San Mateo, I discovered a unique culinary approach that brings a global flair to the classic burger experience. As I sank my teeth into their signature burger, I was delighted by its bold flavors and juicy texture. Each bite was a symphony of savory goodness, perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection.

What sets this place apart is not just the burgers, but also the incredible variety they offer. It’s nearly impossible to settle on just one option! The flavorful choices on the menu have something for everyone, and their crispy chicharrones are the ultimate sidekick to any meal. They are wonderfully crunchy and add a delightful twist that complements the rich burger experience.

While enjoying my meal, I couldn't resist trying their sophisticated mocktails that tickled my taste buds and provided a refreshing palate cleanser between bites. To top it all off, Swing Shift's savory tri tip chili was a perfect accompaniment, enhancing the overall comforting vibe of my dining experience.

In my quest for the best burger in San Mateo, Swing Shift has definitely earned itself a top spot on my list. If you're a burger lover, this gem is not to be missed! 🌟

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Half Moon Bay.

Super Duper Burger

Highlights
Family-friendly atmosphere
Delicious soft serve ice cream
Variety for adults and kids
Unique burger sauce
Organic shakes available

Super Duper Burger is an absolute gem tucked away in San Mateo. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a family-friendly atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. It’s the kind of place where both parents and kids can kick back and enjoy a meal together.

Now, let’s talk about the stars of the show—the burgers! Each bite was an explosion of flavor, with their unique burger sauce adding just the right amount of zing. What I particularly appreciated was their commitment to using high-quality ingredients; the freshness just shines through. And don’t even get me started on the organic shakes—a perfect companion to your burger.

To top it all off, I treated myself to some of their delicious soft serve ice cream. It was a delightful ending to a savory meal. At Super Duper Burger, every element is thoughtfully crafted, offering a delightful variety for both adults and kids alike. If you’re on the hunt for the best burger in San Mateo, this place should be at the top of your list. A perfect blend of nostalgia and modernity, it’s a burger experience you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best cafes in San Francisco.

Godfather's Burger Lounge

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Attentive staff
Good portion sizes
Satisfactory fry on sliders
Prices slightly increased

Godfather's Burger Lounge review in San Mateo

Nestled in the heart of San Mateo, Godfather's Burger Lounge is nothing short of a burger aficionado's playground. Upon walking in, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that welcomes you like an old friend. The staff is genuinely attentive, ensuring every need is met before you even know you have it!

I decided to dive into their signature burger, and oh, what a delightful choice! The portion sizes are generous enough to satisfy even the most ravenous of appetites. Each bite bursts with flavor, making it easy to forget the slight price hike on the menu—though I must say, the quality justifies the splurge.

Accompanying my burger were their sliders, which boasted a satisfactory fry; just crispy enough to add a delightful texture without overshadowing the star of the show. All in all, my experience at Godfather's left me grinning from ear to ear. It's the perfect spot to indulge in a good burger while soaking in the inviting vibes. If you haven't yet stopped by, it's high time to make it a greasy, glorious mission to discover your new favorite burger! 🍔

You might also want to check out the best tacos in San Francisco.

The Swingin' Door

Highlights
Great environment and food
Friendly and knowledgeable bartenders
Excellent seafood combo
Juicy chicken sandwiches
Varieties of drinks available

When I stepped into The Swingin' Door, I was immediately embraced by its warm and inviting atmosphere—perfect for food lovers like me. Nestled among the bustling streets of San Mateo, this gem is not just a burger joint; it's a community hangout. As I scanned the menu, my excitement grew. While they offer an impressive selection of flavors—from juicy chicken sandwiches to enticing seafood combos—my focus was solely on their burgers.

I opted for their signature burger, and oh boy, was it worth it! The patty was succulent and cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of seasoning that made each bite a joyful experience. What I truly appreciated, though, was the thorough knowledge and enthusiasm of the bartenders. They matched my burger with a drink that elevated the meal to a new heights.

I can't help but recommend you swing by The Swingin' Door. With its delightful setting, friendly service, and that astonishing burger, it definitely tops my list as one of San Mateo's finest. Each element combines for an unforgettable meal that simply sings with flavor!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in San Francisco Little Italy.

Bay Watch San Mateo

Highlights
Polite and helpful service
Modern and newly renovated
Extensive menu options
Freshly squeezed orange juice
American diner vibes

Bay Watch San Mateo has certainly earned its place on the burger-loving map of San Mateo! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, thanks to its modern and newly renovated decor. The staff was exceptionally polite and eager to assist, making me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the burger: I decided to go for the classic cheeseburger, and folks, it did not disappoint! The beef patty was cooked to juicy perfection, nestled between two fresh buns that were toasted just right—oh, the heavenly contrast! The toppings were generous and flavorful, enhancing the overall experience.

What truly set Bay Watch apart for me was the extensive menu options they offer. From classic American fare to some inventive takes, there's something for everyone. Plus, I couldn’t resist pairing my meal with their freshly squeezed orange juice—a refreshing addition that complemented my burger beautifully.

In short, these American diner vibes blended seamlessly with delicious food and friendly service! If you find yourself in San Mateo in search of the ultimate burger experience, Bay Watch must be on your list!

You might also want to check out the best food in Alameda.

Rise Woodfire San Mateo

Highlights
Warm and welcoming interior
Quick and friendly service
Great indoor/outdoor vibe
Unique pizza options
Fresh and crispy salads

Review of Rise Woodfire San Mateo

Rise Woodfire San Mateo boasts a warm and welcoming atmosphere that feels like a cozy hug the moment you step inside. The combination of rustic decor and lively chatter contributes to the overall charm. What's even better? The service is incredibly quick and friendly, making you feel right at home from the get-go.

Now, let's talk about the burgers! Once I laid my eyes on their menu, I knew I was in for a treat. The selection is robust, but the woodfire cooking method makes their burgers shine. Imagine sinking your teeth into a juicy burger with a perfectly charred crust that adds delightful smokiness to each bite. This unique touch sets it apart from the typical burger joints.

As a delightful bonus, the range of fresh and crispy salads makes for perfect companions to your meal, perfect for those with lighter cravings or for balancing out the indulgence of the burgers.

Overall, my visit to Rise Woodfire San Mateo was a fantastic experience. The ambiance, swift service, and mouthwatering burgers make it a must-try for anyone in search of the best burger in San Mateo. Don't forget to enjoy the vibe—it's just as tasty!

You might also want to check out the best cookies in San Francisco.

Maverick Jack's San Mateo

At Maverick Jack's San Mateo, I found a paradise for burger lovers! Their signature Maverick burger strikes the perfect balance between juicy beef and cheeky toppings, all tucked into a toasted, buttery bun. The tangy BBQ sauce and crispy bacon add a delightful crunch that keeps your taste buds dancing. The fries were golden and crispy—definitely a worthy sidekick! The atmosphere is casual, inviting, and perfect for enjoying a laid-back meal. If you're on the hunt for a burger that combines flavor and fun, look no further than Maverick Jack's. It's a must-try in San Mateo! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in San Francisco.

Jeffrey's Hamburgers

At Jeffrey's Hamburgers, every bite transports you to burger bliss. The juicy patty is perfectly seasoned, nestled between a soft, buttery bun that just melts in your mouth. As I savored the crisp lettuce and fresh tomato, I couldn't help but appreciate the artful combination of flavors. Their house-made secret sauce adds a delightful tang, elevating this classic meal to extraordinary heights. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff made my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re on a quest for burger perfection in San Mateo, Jeffrey’s is a must-try! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Berkeley.

Sal's Burgers

At Sal's Burgers, I was welcomed by the intoxicating aroma of grilling beef and sizzling toppings. Their classic cheeseburger was a delightful masterpiece, fully clad in a toasted bun that offered a satisfying crunch. The juicy patty oozed flavor with each bite, perfectly complemented by fresh lettuce, tomato, and their signature sauce. What truly impressed me was the balance—each ingredient harmonized wonderfully without overpowering one another. The friendly staff added to the experience, making it a cozy stop on my burger quest. If you’re in search of a burger that sings, Sal’s is definitely worth a visit! 🍔✨

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Oakland.

The Burger

At The Burger, my taste buds took a delightful joyride! The juicy patty, perfectly grilled to a mouthwatering crisp, was complemented by fresh, crunchy toppings that added a burst of flavor. Their homemade sauce? Absolutely divine—it brought the whole ensemble together in a symphony of taste. The toasted bun cradled each ingredient lovingly, ensuring every bite was a blissful experience. If you're hunting for the quintessential burger, look no further. The Burger not only satisfies cravings but also redefines what a great burger should be. I left with a full stomach and a happy heart! 🍔✨

Jack's Restaurant & Bar

Nestled in the heart of San Mateo, Jack's Restaurant & Bar is a burger lover's paradise. I savored the Jack's Burger, a juicy masterpiece topped with crispy bacon and tangy sriracha aioli that adds a delightful kick. The perfectly toasted brioche bun cradles all that flavor, creating a sumptuous bite every time. The ambiance is relaxed yet vibrant, making it an ideal spot to indulge in a satisfying meal. If you're in the mood for a delectable burger that tantalizes your taste buds, you won't want to skip this gem. Trust me, your stomach will thank you! 🍔✨