San Carlos' Best Italian Restaurant

San Carlos has exactly one stoplight worth noting, and it’s surrounded by places claiming to be Italian that mostly are not. You will find Greek salads, German schnitzel, and a cannoli shop that outdoes half the trattorias in San Francisco.

The range runs from counter-service pizza with a killer crab sandwich to a cornmeal deep-dish that justifies the peninsula hype. I ate the beet salad at Elia, the turkey pesto at Sourdough & Co.

, and the pistachio gelato at Gelataio. One of these is not like the others.

That is the point. Here is the list.

Elia San Carlos

Highlights
Dog-friendly sunny afternoon seating
Authentic Greek-style small bites
Fresh, gorgeous beet salad
Tableside baked cheese presentation

Elia San Carlos claims an Italian label, but the kitchen leans Greek. That is fine. The beet salad is fresh and visually striking. The baked cheese arrives tableside, which is a performance worth watching once. Seating outside suits a dog and a slow afternoon. Portions are modest. Prices are not. Service is attentive without hovering. If you want marinara, go elsewhere. If you want feta and olive oil, stay. It is not the best Italian in San Carlos. It might be the best Greek place pretending to be one.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in North Beach San Francisco.

Bistro Mitte

Highlights
Excellent schnitzel with mushroom gravy
Spotless dining room, flawless service
Reasonable prices for German classics
Pleasant patio and indoor seating
Worthwhile apple strudel to close

Bistro Mitte is German, not Italian. I reviewed it anyway because the list demanded it. The schnitzel with mushroom gravy is excellent. The dining room is spotless, and service runs without a hitch. Prices are reasonable for the quality. The patio is pleasant. The strudel is a proper close. You will not find pasta here. You will find precision. That counts for something. If you insist on Italian, skip it. If you want a reliable meal, stay.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in San Francisco Little Italy.

number5kitchen

Highlights
Locally sourced, seasonal prix fixe
Chef often serves personally
Crispy crust, fresh pizza toppings
Steak cooked precisely right
Cozy, family-run atmosphere

number5kitchen does a prix fixe built on local, seasonal goods. The chef often delivers plates himself. That personal touch matters. The pizza has a crisp crust and toppings that taste recent. The steak arrived precisely as ordered. It is a cozy, family-run space. You will not get a menu of endless options. You will get a few things done right. It feels less like a restaurant and more like a hosted dinner. That is fine by me.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Fremont.

Esnaf

Highlights
Attentive, proud service staff
Authentic European street ambiance
Knowledgeable menu recommendations
High-quality Mediterranean flavors
Strong guest-caretaker culture

Esnaf offers European street ambiance without the flight. The staff know the menu and make recommendations with genuine pride. Service is attentive, almost protective. Mediterranean flavors are high quality. The room feels like a busy corner in another country. It is not Italian, strictly speaking. But the care is continental. You leave feeling looked after. That is rare. Order what they suggest. They are usually right.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Berkeley.

Town

Highlights
Solid food, novel options
Outstanding French toast
Attentive, efficient service
Pleasant outdoor seating
Great wine selections

Town does solid food with a few novel twists. The French toast is outstanding, which is not an Italian dish. Service is efficient. Outdoor seating works well. Wine selection is strong. You could come for dinner and be satisfied. You could also come for brunch and be happier. It is a jack-of-all-trades place. Master of none, but decent at most. The pasta is fine. The French toast is the reason to return.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Napa.

New York pizza, pasta & more

Highlights
Counter service, casual takeout
Killer crab sandwich on toast
Crispy thin crust delivered
Bacon calzone worth trying
Friendly owner, quick service

New York pizza, pasta & more is a counter-service operation. It is casual. The crab sandwich on toast is a killer item. The thin crust pizza arrives crispy. The bacon calzone is worth an order. The owner is friendly and quick. You will not linger. You will eat well and leave. That is the point. It is not a destination. It is a neighborhood stop that overdelivers. Takeout is the smart play.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Redwood City.

Blue Line Pizza

Highlights
Best pizza on peninsula
Addictive cornmeal deep-dish crust
Attentive table service
Distinctive West Coast style

Blue Line Pizza has the best pizza on the peninsula. I have tested this claim. The cornmeal deep-dish crust is addictive. It is distinctive West Coast style, not Chicago. Table service is attentive. The place gets busy. It deserves the crowds. If you want a standard slice, they have that too. But the deep-dish is the reason to come. It is a meal, not a snack. Bring appetite.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Oakland.

Romolo's Cannoli

Highlights
Authentic cannolis worth the drive
Multiple filling and topping choices
Crispy shells with flavorful filling
Friendly service in compact shop

Romolo's Cannoli is a compact shop that does one thing well. The cannolis are authentic. Shells are crispy. Fillings are flavorful. You pick from several options. The drive is worth it. Service is friendly. This is not a restaurant. It is a dessert stop. That is its strength. Do not expect seating beyond a few stools. Do expect quality. I have had worse cannolis in actual Italian restaurants. This place beats them all.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurant in San Mateo.

Gelataio

Highlights
Natural, smooth, awesome flavors
Polite, helpful, attentive servers
Unique rotating gelato offerings
Perfect mini hazelnut cones
Pistachio is the standout

Gelataio serves gelato that is natural, smooth, and awesome. The pistachio is the standout. The mini hazelnut cones are perfect. Servers are polite and helpful. Flavors rotate, which keeps things interesting. This is a proper gelato place, not a soft-serve joint. Textures are right. Sweetness is balanced. The shop is small. Lines move fast. Go for the pistachio. You will not regret it.

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurant in San Francisco.

Mykonos

Highlights
Good for family dinners
Quick seating without reservations
Solid food presentation and taste
Pleasant, lively atmosphere

Mykonos is good for a family dinner. You get seated quickly without a reservation. Food presentation is solid. Taste matches presentation. The atmosphere is lively and pleasant. It is not innovative. It is reliable. That has value. The menu covers Greek basics. Portions are appropriate. Service is fine. If you want a quiet, refined meal, look elsewhere. If you want a loud table with decent food, this works.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Berkeley.

Sourdough & Co. Belmont

Highlights
Friendly staff, tasty sandwiches
Turkey pesto sandwich standout
Fresh ingredients, toasted bread
Easy parking, cozy seating

Sourdough & Co. is in Belmont, not San Carlos. I included it anyway. The turkey pesto sandwich is the standout. Bread is toasted. Ingredients taste fresh. Staff is friendly. Parking is easy. Seating is cozy. This is a sandwich shop, not an Italian restaurant. But the pesto and sourdough lean Italian enough. It is a quick lunch option. It will not redefine dining. It will satisfy hunger. That counts.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Fremont.

Bizza (San Mateo)

Highlights
Clean, well-maintained restaurant
Efficient, friendly staff
Excellent White House pizza
Impressive Brotherly Love pizza
Convenient parking and pickup

Bizza is in San Mateo. The dining room is clean and well-maintained. Staff is efficient and friendly. The White House pizza is excellent. The Brotherly Love pizza impresses. Parking and pickup are convenient. This is a solid pizza joint. It does not try to be fancy. It focuses on the pie. That focus pays off. Crust is right. Toppings are generous. If you are driving through, stop. The pizza will not disappoint.

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Palo Alto.